Organic Wear Lip Treatment : The inconsistency of this balm kills me!

I've owned quite a few tubes of this balm and I have mixed feelings about it. I feel there are two different types of this product that they don't denote. First, there is the type that is smooth, glides on the lips and is super moisturizing. Secondly, there is the type that feels more grainy, almost like a lip exfoliant. I literally have two tubes open that I'm using right now and I have one of each. I hate the grainy one but the other that is smooth and moisturizing is probably my favorite lip balm on the market right now. I would repurchase and recommend but I'm not sure which product I would end up with. It's a bit more on the expensive side and it's worth it if you get "the good version" but a total waste for the other.