CeraVe Comforting Eye Makeup Remover with Hyaluronic Acid

I'm not sure if I would by this again.

This eye makeup remover is super gentle on my skin. Love that's it's not irritating to my eyes. It's good at removing eyeshadow. However, I bought it hoping it would tackle waterproof mascara and it's minimally effective for that.

Big no

I do not recommend this at all. It made my vision blurry til the next morning after using it even after trying to wash the product out multiple times. And to get liquid eyeliner and eyelash glue off you have to scrub really hard, "comforting eye" is false advertising

BEST eye remover on the market

I'm honestly so surprised this product has 4 stars. I'm a little bit of a review snob and never buy a product that has less than 4.5 stars, but I bought this on a whim without looking at reviews. I'm so glad I didn't look at reviews because this product is amazing and I have bought 2 bottles so far. I don't wear mascara often but when I do it's usually waterproof or drugstore L'Oréal. It also works great for eyeliner and eyeshadow. There's 0 scent which I prefer. I put this product on a cotton ball and everything melts off super easy. The ONLY issue I have with it is that if it gets in your eye and you're not super careful, it will cloud your vision for a few minutes. When I use it really carefully I don't have any issues. I've tried so many eye make up removers and this one is by far the best. A little bit goes a long way too. I really wouldn't let these reviews deter you..it's worth trying for yourself! You may love it, I definitely do :)

Did not like

I love Cerave products and will not stop buying them. But this product was not good. It left my eyes super cloudy, sensitive, and burned for a bit after. I had to run cold water in my eyes to get the cloudiness to go away.

Does not work well

I used this to remove my Fenty eyeliner and it wasn't able to remove anything. The scent is light if any at all. I did not care for the packaging due to the bottle didn't have a smaller hole for the product to come out. It kinda just dumps out. I love the child resistant lid though.

Won't buy it again

I don't like this product, ineffective, it will take a lot of time to remove makeup, after that my eyes are burn.

Packaging is normal. Good scent. Good ingredients and money. But I would never buy it again.

Not a fan of this eye makeup remover

Unfortunately, this is the worst eye makeup remover I've tried. It didn't take off my mascara which is not waterproof and it really bothered my eyes. It left a white film in my eyes after washing and stung. I had to sit under the sink running water over my eyes for a while to get the film off. I've never had this happen before and makes me leary to use it again.

Burns

I read that this eye makeup remover could help remove eye makeup if you're having and eczema flare up. This was not the case. It burns. Left my eyes super red and swollen. Not your typical cerave quality product.

Love CeraVe, but This is a Dud!

I love CeraVe and have used their products for 20 years; however, this product is a dud. While it doesn't irritate my eye like others have mentioned, it doesn't remove my mascara (which isn't even waterproof). Won't be purchasing or recommending this to anyone.

Garbage - don't buy

This garbage made my eyes sting like crazy and I couldn't see properly due to some weird film and grease in the formula. Plus it was ineffective, left half on the eye makeup on. Buy Clinique eye makeup remover instead, feels so much better and works 100 times more effectively.