Best Eyeko Black Magic Vegan Liquid Eyeliner Alternatives
We found 6 alternatives to Eyeko Black Magic Vegan Liquid Eyeliner based on experts and consumers reviews.
Lottie London AM to PM Retractable Eyeliner

Based on 6 reviews
idk why there are reviews that say "worst eyeliner ever" because this is my ultimate favorite and new go-to. I've been using liquid eyeliners like katVD tattoo because I need something that won't fall off my oily face, and this is it. It gliiiiides on, and allows me to smudge a little and get a smokey effect, and stayed PERFECTLY throughout my 8-her greasy restaurant shift. At night when I washed my face, I got my eyes plenty wet and it still wasn't running down my face. the one I have is this deep charcoal-purply toned black that makes my light brown eyes POP, it is gorgeous. if you're looking for a seamless perfectly cut "sharpie" type liner look, this isn't the product for that. this is more for a soft-edged yet bold liner look. but I'm telling you, I work in a greasy...
L.A. Girl Hyper Cake Eye Liner

Based on 4 reviews
I have always liked cake liner better than any other form of liner. It's so easy to apply, and you have much more control over the line you get. You can get a washed out water color line (which I like on the bottom) or a very bold line. Its also much easier to control the thickness of the line and much easier to make a wing. I also like that you can mix different colors to get your own custom shade. I've had high end cake liners over the years - Chanel used to make wonderful cake liners, and Clinique and Laura Mercier both had nice ones too; but they've all been discontinued. I hung onto the cake liners I had a lot longer than I should have because they are so hard to find. I always look for them on beauty websites, and I am beyond thrilled that I found these! They do not disappoint!...
Undone Beauty Curator Wet to Dry Eye Palette

Based on 112 reviews
"Bare" arrived, colors looked almost muted, I thought, nothing special, through clear lid. Don't judge book by its cover - this is one of those. Today I wetted a liner brush. Gold was the first I tried. I took step back, it deposited bright gold, amazingly pigmented. I haven't had anything quite like this, but WOW. Now I know why so highly rated! Con really isn't a con, as long as there is a liner brush in your makeup kit. I used a small, not even that long liner and it worked beautifully. I highly recommend!
NABLA Cupid's Arrow Longwear Stylo Pencil

Based on 49 reviews
Love Nabla as a brand as a whole for the most part and I love these. I purchased them in 3 of the colors. The black, purple toned and nude shade. I kept the black and purple toned shades. Unfortunately the nude shade was both deeper and pinker then I thought it was going to be. Not brightening at all, so I had to return that one. But they are pigmented. The black is very matte black and smudges very easily and stays in the waterline as well. Doesn't smear, very pigmented and long lasting. And the purple shaded one is the most beautiful shade between a purple and a burgundy. Again super pigmented. Love these. I am going to purchase the brown one next. Hope they will come out with more shades in the future. Like a green or a nice Caramel or Terra-cotta. Or a lighter less pink Nude shade...
Eyeko Limitless Long-Wear Pencil Eyeliner

Based on 15 reviews
Its worth it. Just a little expensive for an eyeliner even on sale. But this is better than ud, marc jacobs (discontinued eyeliner), and more. It doesnt transfer, it's bold, long wearing, glides. I wear 1 heaping tablespoon of spf on my face, neck and hooded eyes and this eyeliner did not budge on my crazy greasy spf face. I also have oily skin, my situation is very oily and its difficult to find eyeliners that look good and stay put. I work outside a lot, hence the sunscreen, this stuff is solid. The other formula they have in a twist up tube is basically the same formula as this, just different packaging.
Urban Decay Cosmetics Heavy Metal Glitter Eyeliner

Based on 169 reviews
Over the past few months, i have collected nine (9!!!) of these. I love them. My family and friends always compliment the glitter lines, and some have purchased for themselves. Ive also bought two as gifts which my friends were super excited about! I've had customers at my work compliment the glitter too! < 3 anyways these are the best, theyre super long lasting (esp if u use a prep/prime spray), and i highly recommend. The only thing is there are not any shades of blue right now— urban decay needs to bring back the blues!! Pls!! For me!! Im begging