Eyeko Black Magic Vegan Liquid Eyeliner Reviews

Rating :

1
2
3
4
5

stars

If you own this item for a while and already published a review somewhere on the internet, you can publish it again here with a custom past date :

1 year ago

Hidden Gem

I took a risk buying this eyeliner and I'm so happy I actually did it. Works better than the bigger names out there. You don't get cheated on the product and run out of it after only 2 weeks of using it. I am obsessed with this eyeliner.. if you are looking to try it, just go ahead and buy it.

2 years ago

Love it

Easy to apply and lasts all day even with my oily eyelids. Wide lash for eyelash growth added perk. Didn't think much of it but I have been getting so many compliments about my eyelashes since I've started using this eyeliner.

3 years ago

I am so disappointed

I am so sad and heartbroken with this purchase. I haven't worn makeup since the pandemic began but have started to go out again and needing makeup.

Over the past year my eyelids have become very oily. My usual go tos (Stila, KVD) have started to melt onto my lid as soon as I put it on because of these new oily lids. Even with primer on they melt right away. I googled and the product was the at the top of the list for oily eyelids. I was delighted to see an earlier post of someone else with oily monolids raving about this eyeliner, which led me to purchase it.

Annddd after two hours it melted. I would say it's not as badly melted as KVD or Stila, but I'm still disappointed. I just want to put an easy liner/mascara look on and don't want to have to use primer and shadow on to make liner last.

I will experiment to see if eye primer will prevent this product from melting and update this later. If not I'm returning it.

3 years ago

Blackest Eyeliner but runs out fast

This is the blackest liquid liner I've tried so far. It is very long lasting and easy to use too...but I felt like it ran out more quickly than other eyeliners I've used. For the price, I just felt like it should've lasted longer.

3 years ago

Best eyeliner I've ever used!

I absolutely LOVE this eyeliner! Definitely the best eyeliner I have ever used. The color is super pigmented black and the applicator allows you to apply the perfect eyeliner with ease. It's also the best to make the cat eye look effortless. LOVE LOVE LOVE!

4 years ago

lasts on oily monolids + 12 hour shifts of manual labor

i found this after researching eyeliners that are oily lid proof & reading some reviews on it.

over the years i've used the epic ink liner from nyx, as well as the flyliner from fenty. these were both great, but i found they flaked or smudged easily from the greasiness on my eyes that would happen throughout the day. or when i cried ahaha.

this eyeliner however, checks all my boxes! as mentioned previously, i have eyelids that get oily throughout the day, and monolids no less. i also work 12 hour shifts at a distribution center. i don't write reviews but i wanted to share my thoughts because this is a holy grail product! it lasts me all day when i'm running around pushing carts and lifting heavy boxes. even after coming to work crying one morning, i got asked later if my eyeliner was tattooed! because it didn't budge! i've been using it for months now and i haven't noticed a difference in my lashes, but it's fine by me!

tl;dr: this eyeliner is oily lid proof on asian monolids that cry often and sweat throughout long shifts of work!

4 years ago

Great all around

I got this in an post bag a year ago. I was pleasantly surprised by how easy it was to use and how smooth it went on. Fair enough price. I have a hard time wanting to dish out 20+ bucks on liquid eyeliners because I fee like there are so many out there that get the job done and are cheaper but this one def stands out to me. No flaking. Not very waterproof though so if you do get watery eyes then it may be risky. Aside from that no complaints.

4 years ago

It actually lasts!

My eyelids are oily, especially since I put jojoba oil on them. Ha, ha. I've never found anything that stayed on my eyelids, even though reviews said it would--until this! I found this by searching for oily eyelid eye liner. So thank you reviewer that led me to this (it was someone's review that connected me to it). I'm still mastering the liquid eye liner technique, but it is getting easier! It really is a skill, and I haven't worn any eye liner forever either. I at first thought the slogan that if you can do liquid eyeliner you can do anything was strange, but now I get it, and it keeps one going when the first few tries look ridiculous. It's looking good now, and getting easier.

4 years ago

Seems dried out

I love the tip! It so easy to draw thin, precise lines and wings. It goes on black and stays all day. I didn't see any cracking of flaking off until after the 12hr mark. The only down side is the tip feel pretty dry. I had to put the cap back on and give it a good shake once or twice per eye, even with storing the pen vertically, tip side down. I hope it doesn't dry out too fast. I haven't used it long enough to see any benefit/conditioning of my lashes yet.

4 years ago

Internal black eye

During application the liner became runny and went into my eye. It was the scariest thing, my entire eye turned black and burned. I took my contact off and the contact itself was black. My eye hurts and have a left side headache from it. I have been applying eyeliner for 24 years and have used a wide variety and this has never happened. Don't recommend for contact lens users, I don't recommend at all for this reason.

4 years ago

Thin color but holds well

I've been using Nyx Epic Ink liner but wanted to try to find something that smudged less. Decided to try this one. Had a lot of good reviews, bold black color and was a fine brush tip (instead of felt tip). Tried it and was rather disappointed. Some of the bad reviews for this loner were about thin ink. I was hoping I wouldn't think that once I tried it but I was very wrong. The ink is VERY thin with pigment and it doesn't improve if you go over the line more than once. The line bled slightly too, which sucks.

The plus side of this liner, it holds up very well and doesn't smudge near as much as what I'd been using. That I loved.

But...I want a bold solid line when I use eye liner. Not a thin pigment. I'll def use this until it's gone but I probably won't buy again.

4 years ago

I was a Stila girl... until I tried this!!

Love how easily it glides on and and stays on. The color is great, the brush allows for thin or thick lines. I also noticed that I did not have to buy it as often - perhaps more liner in the pencil than my past brand? I was a Stila liquid eyeliner girl for years until I tried this. Worst part is that it is FB only available online.

4 years ago

Never going back..

I've tried it all.. and by far, this is my favorite. Some stay long formulas are super harsh and hard to remove, but this one comes off with basic face washing yet stays on all day, the brush is PERFECT and I never had an issue with it drying out. I've been using it for almost two weeks straight with thick wings daily and even went swimming with it on! I've noticed since I've started using it my lashes seem stronger and I dont notice as much thinning (I wear false lashes daily) but it's too early to tell with that.. but I really like the formula, and definitely buying again.

4 years ago

Leaky and runny

Upon opening the top was cracked. Figured it was just a tiny leak and that the eyeliner would still work the same. It came out really really liquid, the texture of pure water. Normally my liquid eyeliners are indeed liquid, but this was so much runnier and wouldn't dry. It just sat on my eye, wet and runny. When it started to dry down, which it never did completely, it was patchy and spread apart. Very disappointing.

4 years ago

Pigment wont mix- bad batch

I have been using this eyeliner for 2 years & love it...until this last order. I purchased 4 & the pigment has either settled or there is very little. You cant even make a solid line, its all watery. I shook each one for a week. Every time I thought about it I would shake it a lot hoping the pigment had just settled. No luck, all 4 are useless. I'm hoping to exchange them with the in-store stock. Hopefully this was a bad batch & not a product change.

4 years ago

So liquidy...

This is so liquidy that if you have any fine lines at all the it will find them and seep into them. Will not create a straight line. Is not as dark black as other eyeliners. Will never purchase again. Should have stuck yo my normal eyeliner, but caught this one on sale.

4 years ago

Terrible color payoff

Watery color, not a dark solid black as advertised no matter how much I shake it first. I don't mind the brush tip but without pigment it's like what's the point? Got it on sale but still a waste of money and can't currently return to a physical store and don't want to spend money to ship it back.

4 years ago

I would buy again

The flow is much better than the eye do liner. A little shiny for my taste but nice and dark. Lasted all day and after a nap. Had just a hint of smudge under eye by the end of the day. I like the consistency so that it doesn't leave chunks on eyelashes. This will be my night out liner.

4 years ago

Amazing!

I've tried almost every eyeliner on the market. I don't know if I just have oily eyelids or if I don't use enough translucent powder to set my makeup. Every eyeliner always smudged my under eye area about halfway through the day. This eyeliner lasted all day. I created a cat eye liner and it didn't budge. Will definitely repurchase after it dries out!

4 years ago

Great when on but oh so LEAKY

This liquid eyeliner is awesome on the eyes; stays put and is the perfect black. But Eyeko needs to revisit their pen because every Eyeko liquid liner I e had (several) always wind up leaking and it's a hot mess. Worst part is the liner is so good that it's hard to get off whatever it spills onto.

Image Eyeko Black Magic Vegan Liquid Eyeliner

Technical Data

  • Manufactured by Eyeko
  • Average price : $22
Share linkedin post Tweet Share