Eyeko Black Magic Vegan Liquid Eyeliner 1-star Reviews
Internal black eye
During application the liner became runny and went into my eye. It was the scariest thing, my entire eye turned black and burned. I took my contact off and the contact itself was black. My eye hurts and have a left side headache from it. I have been applying eyeliner for 24 years and have used a wide variety and this has never happened. Don't recommend for contact lens users, I don't recommend at all for this reason.
Leaky and runny
Upon opening the top was cracked. Figured it was just a tiny leak and that the eyeliner would still work the same. It came out really really liquid, the texture of pure water. Normally my liquid eyeliners are indeed liquid, but this was so much runnier and wouldn't dry. It just sat on my eye, wet and runny. When it started to dry down, which it never did completely, it was patchy and spread apart. Very disappointing.
Pigment wont mix- bad batch
I have been using this eyeliner for 2 years & love it...until this last order. I purchased 4 & the pigment has either settled or there is very little. You cant even make a solid line, its all watery. I shook each one for a week. Every time I thought about it I would shake it a lot hoping the pigment had just settled. No luck, all 4 are useless. I'm hoping to exchange them with the in-store stock. Hopefully this was a bad batch & not a product change.
So liquidy...
This is so liquidy that if you have any fine lines at all the it will find them and seep into them. Will not create a straight line. Is not as dark black as other eyeliners. Will never purchase again. Should have stuck yo my normal eyeliner, but caught this one on sale.
Terrible! Don't recommend
I have pretty oily eyelids and this eyeliner slides around so much I had to reapply it so many times so my eyeliner could look decent. It also fades to a grayish color which is I assume the eyeliner mixing with my foundation throughout the day. My nyx matte liquid eyeliner works so much better for less than half the price. No thanks.
Fail for me
I purchased this during the 21 days of beauty sale. It has really good reviews so I thought I would try it out. I first swatched it on my hand and it was so watery and not pigmented at all. I shook it up for a while and tried it on my eye and it was horrible. I'm guessing got a bad one. I returned it and will not be purchasing again.
Very Disappointed
I was so excited to see this on the 21 Days of deals because I had been wanting to try it. The eyeliner is precise and goes on beautifully. HOWEVER, it is definitely not smudge proof and comes off SO EASY from water or sweat. Maybe it's because I have oily skin (I'm not sure) but I had several occasions on which I touched around my eye and the eyeliner wiped right off. And wearing it to the gym (I was in a hurry and didn't have time to remove it) was an absolute nightmare. Black ink everywhere. I definitely don't recommend it, especially because of the price.
Technical Data
- Manufactured by Eyeko
- Average price : $22
