Eyeko Black Magic Vegan Liquid Eyeliner 5-stars Reviews

Rating :

1
2
3
4
5

stars

If you own this item for a while and already published a review somewhere on the internet, you can publish it again here with a custom past date :

1 year ago

Hidden Gem

I took a risk buying this eyeliner and I'm so happy I actually did it. Works better than the bigger names out there. You don't get cheated on the product and run out of it after only 2 weeks of using it. I am obsessed with this eyeliner.. if you are looking to try it, just go ahead and buy it.

2 years ago

Love it

Easy to apply and lasts all day even with my oily eyelids. Wide lash for eyelash growth added perk. Didn't think much of it but I have been getting so many compliments about my eyelashes since I've started using this eyeliner.

3 years ago

Best eyeliner I've ever used!

I absolutely LOVE this eyeliner! Definitely the best eyeliner I have ever used. The color is super pigmented black and the applicator allows you to apply the perfect eyeliner with ease. It's also the best to make the cat eye look effortless. LOVE LOVE LOVE!

4 years ago

lasts on oily monolids + 12 hour shifts of manual labor

i found this after researching eyeliners that are oily lid proof & reading some reviews on it.

over the years i've used the epic ink liner from nyx, as well as the flyliner from fenty. these were both great, but i found they flaked or smudged easily from the greasiness on my eyes that would happen throughout the day. or when i cried ahaha.

this eyeliner however, checks all my boxes! as mentioned previously, i have eyelids that get oily throughout the day, and monolids no less. i also work 12 hour shifts at a distribution center. i don't write reviews but i wanted to share my thoughts because this is a holy grail product! it lasts me all day when i'm running around pushing carts and lifting heavy boxes. even after coming to work crying one morning, i got asked later if my eyeliner was tattooed! because it didn't budge! i've been using it for months now and i haven't noticed a difference in my lashes, but it's fine by me!

tl;dr: this eyeliner is oily lid proof on asian monolids that cry often and sweat throughout long shifts of work!

4 years ago

It actually lasts!

My eyelids are oily, especially since I put jojoba oil on them. Ha, ha. I've never found anything that stayed on my eyelids, even though reviews said it would--until this! I found this by searching for oily eyelid eye liner. So thank you reviewer that led me to this (it was someone's review that connected me to it). I'm still mastering the liquid eye liner technique, but it is getting easier! It really is a skill, and I haven't worn any eye liner forever either. I at first thought the slogan that if you can do liquid eyeliner you can do anything was strange, but now I get it, and it keeps one going when the first few tries look ridiculous. It's looking good now, and getting easier.

4 years ago

I was a Stila girl... until I tried this!!

Love how easily it glides on and and stays on. The color is great, the brush allows for thin or thick lines. I also noticed that I did not have to buy it as often - perhaps more liner in the pencil than my past brand? I was a Stila liquid eyeliner girl for years until I tried this. Worst part is that it is FB only available online.

4 years ago

Never going back..

I've tried it all.. and by far, this is my favorite. Some stay long formulas are super harsh and hard to remove, but this one comes off with basic face washing yet stays on all day, the brush is PERFECT and I never had an issue with it drying out. I've been using it for almost two weeks straight with thick wings daily and even went swimming with it on! I've noticed since I've started using it my lashes seem stronger and I dont notice as much thinning (I wear false lashes daily) but it's too early to tell with that.. but I really like the formula, and definitely buying again.

4 years ago

Amazing!

I've tried almost every eyeliner on the market. I don't know if I just have oily eyelids or if I don't use enough translucent powder to set my makeup. Every eyeliner always smudged my under eye area about halfway through the day. This eyeliner lasted all day. I created a cat eye liner and it didn't budge. Will definitely repurchase after it dries out!

5 years ago

Love the tip, stays all day

Flexible fine tip is great for creating a winged look. Tip is made of bristles rather than a felt tip, allowing for precision application and detail. Received this in a subscription box and it has become my new go-to. Came here to buy a new one!

5 years ago

Excellent product

I first got this liner in an Ipsy bag and another one a couple of months later in another box (allure maybe?). I use pen liners almost exclusively, and Stila's most of all. This deliciously dark and precise pen is my new favorite. The applicator is great - a very fine brush-like top. So far it hasn't shed any of those tiny fuzzies like a traditional felt tip liner is want to do. Love the formula too. With hooded eyes now in my mature years, I need a very fine line and this magic pen does that very well.

5 years ago

My HG for liquid liner!

I immediately loved this as soon as I used it the first time. I have never been good at a cat eye or winged liner look. Shaky bumpy lines and tough to get the line right up next to my lash line. But the tip, shape and formula of this product makes it so easy for me. As soon as I used this, I seemed to have much more skill with making a straight, smooth line. It goes on super thin but with a smooth, defined line that you can really easily build to make thicker. I have never experienced smudging, fading or any issues. It literally lasts all day. It dries quickly but not too quickly, as sometimes I like to run over my liner with a tiny detail brush to soften and this stuff does exactly what i want it to do. I will never use another liquid liner again!

5 years ago

Buying again

I love this product. I got the mini travel size in Ipsy and I'm running out so I'm going to order the full size for my wedding day in October. It is a little hard to be super precise but I also am no makeup artist haha

5 years ago

The best liquid eyeliner marker for cat eyes!

I got this eyeliner in my Ipsy bag this month. I've been using it NON STOP. I've stayed away from eyeliner markers in the past because they seem to run out so quickly or begin working unevenly. I don't know how it works, but it's always even and wet when I'm using it. I love the calligraphy "brush" design, as it makes it almost effortless to build your desired cat eye. This will 100% be my go to in the future.

5 years ago

Best ever.

I actually received this through Birchbox and it's nice to have something you can test without wasting your money and I'm so glad I did, this is my favorite eyeliner ever, no complaints. It's so easy to use and it's good practice when you're new with doing your own Cat eye. This would be the perfect eyeliner, I'm gonna buy this for now one, regardless of the price because it's so worth it, Thankyou Birchbox!

5 years ago

Best ever

I'm literally appalled at how many bad reviews I just read. I have been using all kinds of different liquid eyeliners over the past few years I do wings everyday so I go thought a lot. I get different ones every time hoping to finally find the perfect one and this literally tops them all by 1000

5 years ago

I bought this a year ago and it still isn't out of ink

I bought this last year as part of the 21 Days of Beauty sale and it's still kickin! I don't wear it everyday but it is still going. It started running out a little bit, so I bought another one during the sale this year for when it finally uses up all the ink. I love this eyeliner though, it's so worth the money- it's just a bonus when it's on sale

5 years ago

Best Liner!

I have been an NYC liner fan for years and after being down to my last one I went on a hunt for an eyeliner that was extremely black, applied smoothly, and was waterproof. This eyeliner does all three. I don't know how long it will last being a marker liner and all, but that will be put to the test.

6 years ago

Good for oily eyelids

I generally don't wear makeup unless I'm going out for the night. I have oily eyelids so most liners don't make it through the night without turning me into a raccoon. This one stayed in place despite my oily lids and sweat from a night of dancing.

It produces a nice, thin, constant line of liner and the fine tip made it easy to apply between my lashes.

6 years ago

Best Liquid liner ever.

I first got to try this brand when Birchbox was good... lol it came with Eyeko's "Fat line" liner that was 4 years ago now, and guess what the liner still has ink in it. It still works perfectly and I use it 3-4x a week. So I have absolutely no doubt there liners are the absolute best.

6 years ago

So good!

Pigmentation? Check. No smudges? Check. Lasts all day? Eyeko's got you! Whether you like it thick or thin, this Eyeko Black Magic Eyeliner offers the best application with it's brush tip. It has enough flexibility to give you that sharp liner you've been looking for and it's also great for beginners! As an add in, it contains Widelash with a tripeptide boost to promote lash growth, who wouldn't want that? This is a 10/10 in my book!

Image Eyeko Black Magic Vegan Liquid Eyeliner

Technical Data

  • Manufactured by Eyeko
  • Average price : $22
Share linkedin post Tweet Share