Eyeko Eyeko Skinny Liquid Eye Liner 3-stars Reviews
Really like this but faulty packaging
I received this first as a mini and loved it. I bought a full sized & was VERY disappointed because a couple weeks into using it, a plastic piece within the cap fell out. I didn't think it was anything important but then the eyeliner dried up within a week after that, which did not happen with the mini so I believe it was due to the plastic piece. I'm torn because I loved this eyeliner but am afraid that would happen again.
Great at first but dries out quickly
I really liked this when it was fresh out of the package. However I felt like after only a few weeks (even less) the product dried up and didn't apply nicely as before. For the price, I expect it to last a long time.
Not as good as it used to be
Had this when it was in the silver pen and it was the best ever. Didn't run or smear and I could compete in competitive swim with my makeup still on. This reformulation, though is not as good. My eyes are relatively watery and so whenever they do, this smears and doesn't last as long. Good if your eyes aren't watery or don't deal with sweating. Other than that the color is really bold.
Good but smudges
Normally for eyeliner I do a winged eye, and I bought this liner as well as the Nudestix Rollerball Liner. I was using the rollerball for just the wing and this eyeko liner for my top lash line. I like to get very close to the lash line, especially near the inner corner of my eye. The color is very bold and the tip makes it very easy to apply. I wore this liner twice for two separate nights out and within 3 hrs each time, it had all smudged near my inner corner (because it was really close to my waterline) and was underneath my eye. I've never had this happen with an eyeliner before. I've tried a lot of liners so this was kind of a disappointment to me. Unfortunately, I don't think I'd repurchase.
I like it but
This isn't really a smidge proof liner. Or waterproof liner. What I like about it is the felt tip and how easy it is to apply... I will say that if yours comes in a bit dried out just run the liner with the cap securely on in hot water. That should help.
Smears
I didn't really like this liner because the felt tip is super hard and felt like it was scratching my eyelid as I applied it. The formula also doesn't set, so it smudges and smears throughout the day, and it sweats off. Overall, not my favorite.
Great at first, now not so much.
Ok, so I received a trial size of this eyeliner and I absolutely ADORED it. It went on smooth and pitch black, which I loved. I loved it so much I ordered the full-size. However, after about a month and a half, the felt tip of the eyeliner seems to have dried out on both my trial size and my full size. I'm completely unable to get a good, reliable cat eye without some pretty serious clean up.
All in all, it was awesome at first and definitely wouldn't come off on your eyelids. But that doesn't mean much if you can't get the product where you want it in the first place.

Technical Data
- Manufactured by Eyeko
- Average price : $22